title -> selectionReason - 2016-09 core #354

XMLWordPrintableJSON

    • Type: Change Request
    • Resolution: Persuasive with Modification
    • Priority: Medium
    • FHIR Core (FHIR)
    • DSTU2
    • Imaging Integration
    • ImagingManifest [deprecated]
    • Hide

      Due to the limited scope of Imaging Manifest, this field which maps directly from from the DICOM KOS is not needed.

      Remove the title field.

      Change the ImagingManifest.description definition to "A text description of the DICOM SOP instances selected in the ImagingManifest; or the reason for, or significance of, the selection." Remove ImagingManifest.description requirements. Change ImagingManifest.description to "Free text narrative description of the ImagingManifest. _<new paragraph> _The value may be derived from the DICOM Standard Part 16, CID-7010 descriptions (e.g. Best in Set, Complete Study Content). Note that those values cover the wide range of uses of the DICOM Key Object Selection object, several of which are not supported by ImagingManifest. Specifically, there is no expected behavior associated with descriptions that suggest referenced images be removed or not used."

      Remove the title search parameter.

      Show
      Due to the limited scope of Imaging Manifest, this field which maps directly from from the DICOM KOS is not needed. Remove the title field. Change the ImagingManifest.description definition to "A text description of the DICOM SOP instances selected in the ImagingManifest; or the reason for, or significance of, the selection." Remove ImagingManifest.description requirements. Change ImagingManifest.description to "Free text narrative description of the ImagingManifest. _<new paragraph> _The value may be derived from the DICOM Standard Part 16, CID-7010 descriptions (e.g. Best in Set, Complete Study Content). Note that those values cover the wide range of uses of the DICOM Key Object Selection object, several of which are not supported by ImagingManifest. Specifically, there is no expected behavior associated with descriptions that suggest referenced images be removed or not used." Remove the title search parameter.
    • Richard Esmond/Elliot Silver:6-0-0
    • Clarification
    • Compatible, substantive
    • DSTU2

      Comment:

      ImagingManifest.title = Reason or significance for selection the image

      The concept name "title" is a misfit for the definition and is confusing

      Suggest rename to: "selectionReason"

      Summary:

      title -> selectionReason

            Assignee:
            Unassigned
            Reporter:
            Stephen Chu
            Watchers:
            2 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: