Need section describing coordinate systems - 2016-09 core #387

XMLWordPrintableJSON

    • Type: Change Request
    • Resolution: Persuasive
    • Priority: Medium
    • FHIR Core (FHIR)
    • DSTU2
    • Clinical Genomics
    • MolecularSequence (was Sequence)
    • (profiles)
    • Genomics Implementat
    • Hide

      This short discription can be found at here

      https://bcl-lab.github.io/FHIR_CG_web/sequence.html#resource

      The plain text should be:

      When saving the variant information, the nucleic acid will be numbered with order. Some files are using 0-based coordiantes (e.g. BCD file format) while some files are using 1-based coordinates (e.g. VCF file format) . The element coordinateSystem in Sequence Resource contains this information.

      Sequence.coordinateSystem constraints within two possible values: 0 for 0-based system, which will mark the sequence from number 0, while 1 for 1-based system, which will begin marking the first position with number 1. The significant difference between two system is the end position. In 0-based system, the end position is exclusive , which means the last position will not be contained in the sequence window while in 1-based system, the end position is inclusive , which means the last position is included in the sequence window. Note both systems has an inclusive start position.

      For example, ACGTGCAT will be numbered from 1 to 8 in 1-based system and will be numbered from 0 to 8 in 0-based system to mark flanks (i.e. place between two Nucleotide). So the interval [3,5] in 1-based system is GTG while interval [2,5) in 0-based system is same segment GTG.

      Besides, there is one slide (see attachment) that can be further implemented into Implementation Guide if people need better , clear exapainlation of coordinateSystem. Also, we provide two simple example (ideal case) to use both coordinateSystem.

      Check preview of two examples at:

      https://bcl-lab.github.io/FHIR_CG_web/coord-1base-example.html

      https://bcl-lab.github.io/FHIR_CG_web/coord-0base-example.html

      Show
      This short discription can be found at here https://bcl-lab.github.io/FHIR_CG_web/sequence.html#resource The plain text should be: When saving the variant information, the nucleic acid will be numbered with order. Some files are using 0-based coordiantes (e.g. BCD file format) while some files are using 1-based coordinates (e.g. VCF file format) . The element coordinateSystem in Sequence Resource contains this information. Sequence.coordinateSystem constraints within two possible values: 0 for 0-based system, which will mark the sequence from number 0, while 1 for 1-based system, which will begin marking the first position with number 1. The significant difference between two system is the end position. In 0-based system, the end position is exclusive , which means the last position will not be contained in the sequence window while in 1-based system, the end position is inclusive , which means the last position is included in the sequence window. Note both systems has an inclusive start position. For example, ACGTGCAT will be numbered from 1 to 8 in 1-based system and will be numbered from 0 to 8 in 0-based system to mark flanks (i.e. place between two Nucleotide). So the interval [3,5] in 1-based system is GTG while interval [2,5) in 0-based system is same segment GTG. Besides, there is one slide (see attachment) that can be further implemented into Implementation Guide if people need better , clear exapainlation of coordinateSystem. Also, we provide two simple example (ideal case) to use both coordinateSystem. Check preview of two examples at: https://bcl-lab.github.io/FHIR_CG_web/coord-1base-example.html https://bcl-lab.github.io/FHIR_CG_web/coord-0base-example.html
    • David Kreda/Clem McDownload: 25-0-2
    • Enhancement
    • Non-substantive
    • DSTU2

      Comment:

      There needs to be a section describing coordinate systems, including not only 0 and 1-based, but also what open/closed means for start/end. This is imperative for understanding how to use the Sequence Resource

      Summary:

      Need section describing coordinate systems

        1. coord-0base-example.xml
          1 kB
          panzerwy
        2. coord-0base-example.xml
          1 kB
          panzerwy
        3. coord-1base-example.xml
          1 kB
          panzerwy
        4. coord-1base-example.xml
          1 kB
          panzerwy
        5. coordinateSystem 1.pdf
          394 kB
          panzerwy
        6. coordinateSystem 1.pdf
          394 kB
          panzerwy

            Assignee:
            Unassigned
            Reporter:
            Bob Milius
            Watchers:
            2 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: