ImmunizationRecommendation fails to address Immunization Orders or Recommendations to Patient

XMLWordPrintableJSON

    • Type: Change Request
    • Resolution: Not Persuasive
    • Priority: Medium
    • FHIR Core (FHIR)
    • STU3
    • Public Health
    • STU
    • ImmunizationRecommendation
    • Hide

      This will be resolved as part of R5 and will not be addressed in R4.

      Our recommendation is that that any immunization order should use the MedicationRequest resource. In order to accomplish this, we will need to make a change to MedicationRequest.basedOn to include a reference to ImmunizationRecommendation. If/When an "ordering immunizations" IG is written, MedicationRequest will be profiled so that immunization orders can only use a MedicationRequest.intent value "order" (or other flavors of an order) but not a "proposal" or "plan".

      Show
      This will be resolved as part of R5 and will not be addressed in R4. Our recommendation is that that any immunization order should use the MedicationRequest resource. In order to accomplish this, we will need to make a change to MedicationRequest.basedOn to include a reference to ImmunizationRecommendation. If/When an "ordering immunizations" IG is written, MedicationRequest will be profiled so that immunization orders can only use a MedicationRequest.intent value "order" (or other flavors of an order) but not a "proposal" or "plan".
    • Craig Newman/Jojhn Roberts: 10-0-0
    • Enhancement

      ImmunizationRecommendation is currently modeled as a resource to represent an immunization forecast from a clinical decision support service which might be performed and sent from within the EHR software, from an immunization registry (Immunization Information System) or a third party, web-based query or a SMART app.

      However, there is no reference in FHIR about how to manage an order for an immunization or a recommendation from a provider to a patient that an immunization is required or expected. MedicationRequest provides such a possibility using the .intent _metadata element in which the * _plan * element is most consistent with a recommendation to the patient and the order element is most consistent with an * order *. ProcedureRequest and ReferralRequest are similarly modeled. And, in FHIR STU 4, there is consideration to merge such requests into ServiceRequest. There are steps within a clinical workflow in which a provider receives the forecast (the current ImmunizationRecommendation) from which the provider orders the immunization/vaccine. In some cases, the order is a prescription filled by a pharmacist and the patient picks up the immunization and returns to the physician office to have it administered (or has it administered at the pharmacy). The order should include metadata elements not present in the ImmunizationRecommendation resource: orderQuantity and route of anticipated administration, and source (i.e., should the immunization come from specific guarantee program inventory or should it come from non-guarantee program inventory (or other possible inventory designations).

      Bottom line - Immunization should address modeling similar to other resources, especially medication or at the very least, clear guidance should be included about which resource to use when. (E.g., for immunization request, use MedicationRequest resource) and assure the referenced resource includes the metadata elements requried to successfully met the use case.

            Assignee:
            Unassigned
            Reporter:
            Floyd Eisenberg
            Floyd Eisenberg
            Watchers:
            1 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: