The CDex CommunicationRequest should be removed from this IG in favor the simple and widely implemented RESTful FHIR APIs. - PCDE #100

XMLWordPrintableJSON

    • Type: Change Request
    • Resolution: Not Persuasive
    • Priority: Medium
    • US Da Vinci PCDE (FHIR)
    • STU3
    • Financial Mgmt
    • (profiles) [deprecated]
    • Hide

      The business case here does not allow query of the information needed to be retrieved. The request results in a human assembling data into a document.  There is no way one payer will allow another payer to query and go digging through data on the patient via query.  The source payer will specifically decide on what information is necessary to deliver continuity of care, will filter data if needed, and package it in a way that provides context. At least for now, this will be an asynchronous process. If it gets to the point where it can be automated for certain types of patients/conditions/care, it will still be a patient-specific operation and not a standard query.  In short, RESTful query can't produce what we're looking for.

      Show
      The business case here does not allow query of the information needed to be retrieved. The request results in a human assembling data into a document.  There is no way one payer will allow another payer to query and go digging through data on the patient via query.  The source payer will specifically decide on what information is necessary to deliver continuity of care, will filter data if needed, and package it in a way that provides context. At least for now, this will be an asynchronous process. If it gets to the point where it can be automated for certain types of patients/conditions/care, it will still be a patient-specific operation and not a standard query.  In short, RESTful query can't produce what we're looking for.
    • Mark Scrimshire / Mary Kay McDaniel: 17-0-2

      Comment:

      The Cdex CommunicationRequest confuses system-level communication with person-level communication. Further, it hampers interoperability by duplicating the intent and superior features of FHIR Messaging. It should be removed from this IG in favor the simple and widely implemented RESTful FHIR APIs.

      Summary:

      The CDex CommunicationRequest should be removed from this IG in favor the simple and widely implemented RESTful FHIR APIs.

            Assignee:
            Unassigned
            Reporter:
            Isaac Vetter
            Watchers:
            4 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: