Clarify US Public Health ValueSet Profile

XMLWordPrintableJSON

    • Type: Change Request
    • Resolution: Persuasive with Modification
    • Priority: Medium
    • Electronic Case Reporting (FHIR)
    • 1.1.0 [deprecated]
    • Public Health
    • US Public Health Value Set
    • Hide

      Consider the following clarifications for the US Public Health Value Set:

      1. What does the mustSupport on identifier mean? What kind of identifiers must be supported? How will those identifiers be used, for what, and by whom?
        • We will clarify as suggested
      2. What is the difference between the use of the valueset-steward extension and the publisher element? They appear to be duplicate, consider removing the valueset-steward extension from the profile
        • Agreed they are duplicate - will remove as suggested
      3. Shareable requires name and description, why restate this in the profile?
        • This is the only way to add further descriptions and mappings to data elements that haven't changed in the profile - will leave as is
      4. The base ValueSet requires status, why restate in this in the profile?
        • This is the only way to add further descriptions and mappings to data elements that haven't changed in the profile - will leave as is
      Show
      Consider the following clarifications for the US Public Health Value Set: What does the mustSupport on identifier mean? What kind of identifiers must be supported? How will those identifiers be used, for what, and by whom? We will clarify as suggested What is the difference between the use of the valueset-steward extension and the publisher element? They appear to be duplicate, consider removing the valueset-steward extension from the profile Agreed they are duplicate - will remove as suggested Shareable requires name and description, why restate this in the profile? This is the only way to add further descriptions and mappings to data elements that haven't changed in the profile - will leave as is The base ValueSet requires status, why restate in this in the profile? This is the only way to add further descriptions and mappings to data elements that haven't changed in the profile - will leave as is
    • Sarah Gaunt / John Loonsk : 20 - 0 - 0
    • Correction
    • Compatible, substantive

      Consider the following clarifications for the US Public Health Value Set:

      1. What does the mustSupport on identifier mean? What kind of identifiers must be supported? How will those identifiers be used, for what, and by whom?
      2. What is the difference between the use of the valueset-steward extension and the publisher element? They appear to be duplicate, consider removing the valueset-steward extension from the profile
      3. Shareable requires name and description, why restate this in the profile?
      4. The base ValueSet requires status, why restate in this in the profile?

            Assignee:
            Sarah Gaunt
            Reporter:
            Bryn Rhodes
            Watchers:
            1 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: