Jan 2015 Ballot Comment #16

XMLWordPrintableJSON

    • Type: Change Request
    • Resolution: Persuasive with Modification
    • Priority: Medium
    • FHIR Core (FHIR)
    • DSTU1 [deprecated]
    • Structured Documents
    • Composition
    • 6.9
    • Hide

      Current Disposition: 3/5/2015

      3/5/2015 - Motion to reopen Rick G/Brett M - passed unanimously.

      Revised Disposition: We will go forward with the existing model that went to ballot in January, with the change that the reference to ANY resource is constrained to List.
      Update the description of List.text to make it consistent with its use as section narrative as well as List narrative (i.e. not just a summary of the list content).?
      When list is included as a section, that text of the list is the authenticated content.?
      When the section content is naturally narrative only, the reference would still be to a List (not Basic) with an appropriate emptyReason code.

      Motion: Rgeimer/Bmarquard

      Vote: For unanimous

      Prior Disposition: 1/22/2015

      Motion: Adopt the modeling of section as presented by Calvin. See SDWG minutes, Q3, Thursday, Jan 22nd.

      CBeebe/Kconan

      Vote: For 8, Abstain 9,? Against 2

      Show
      Current Disposition: 3/5/2015 3/5/2015 - Motion to reopen Rick G/Brett M - passed unanimously. Revised Disposition: We will go forward with the existing model that went to ballot in January, with the change that the reference to ANY resource is constrained to List. Update the description of List.text to make it consistent with its use as section narrative as well as List narrative (i.e. not just a summary of the list content).? When list is included as a section, that text of the list is the authenticated content.? When the section content is naturally narrative only, the reference would still be to a List (not Basic) with an appropriate emptyReason code. Motion: Rgeimer/Bmarquard Vote: For unanimous Prior Disposition: 1/22/2015 Motion: Adopt the modeling of section as presented by Calvin. See SDWG minutes, Q3, Thursday, Jan 22nd. CBeebe/Kconan Vote: For 8, Abstain 9,? Against 2
    • Clarification
    • Non-compatible
    • DSTU1 [deprecated]

      Existing Wording
      The composition section defines a section (or sub-section) of the document, but unlike in CDA, the section content is actually a reference to another resource that actually holds both the narrative and data content for the section. This design means that the narrative and data can be reused in many other ways. Note that the most common resource to use for the content of a section is the List resource.

      Proposed Wording
      The composition section defines a section (or sub-section) of the document. Like CDA, the section contains the human readable narrative (text). It will also contain a set of references to the underlying resources that were used to construct the text. This design supports the reuse of resources while enabling the construction of authenticated text within documents.

      A composition can be authenticated as needed and when dealing with a narrative document, the composition as a whole needs to be reviewed.

      Comments
      The current design enables both a single resource or a list as the sole content item in a given Section. If a document is sent with a single resource and then updated to remove the item, a list will need to be utilized to indicate the emptyReason. If a document is sent with a single item, and then updated to add additional items, a list will need to be used to enable the processing. This optionality serves no beneficial purpose and can be eliminated by simply extending the section to support text like CDA. (See Diagrams tab for proposed revision)

      Grahame's Comments
      Add documentation to make clear that a List must be used whenever there is a possibility of either 0 mor more than 1 item. Having a non-list resource directly referenced can only occur if there is guaranteed to be exactly one resource if the section is present

      Disposition
      Persuasive with mod

      Disposition Comment
      Add documentation to make clear that a List must be used whenever there is a possibility of either 0 mor more than 1 item. Having a non-list resource directly referenced can only occur if there is guaranteed to be exactly one resource if the section is present

            Assignee:
            Unassigned
            Reporter:
            Calvin E. Beebe
            Calvin E. Beebe
            Watchers:
            2 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: