Loading...

XML

Word

Printable

JSON

Specification:

FHIR Core (FHIR)
Raised in Version:

DSTU1 [deprecated]
Work Group:

FHIR Infrastructure
Related URL:
http://hl7.org/fhir/2015May/http.html#2.1.0.5.2
Related Page(s):

REST (http)
Related Section(s):
2.1.0.5.2
Resolution Description:

Hide

The idea is that it is likely that data will be transformed, and by not returning you stimulate client behaviour to not verify the data.

We believe that clients who choose not to validate the data will ignore the data even if the server returns it, so this argument is not persuasive. Seeing the clear benefits in the mobile/low bandwidth space, we choose to keep the current behaviour.

Show
The idea is that it is likely that data will be transformed, and by not returning you stimulate client behaviour to not verify the data. We believe that clients who choose not to validate the data will ignore the data even if the server returns it, so this argument is not persuasive. Seeing the clear benefits in the mobile/low bandwidth space, we choose to keep the current behaviour.
Resolution Vote:
Josh Mandel / David Hay: 17-0-2
Change Category:
Enhancement

Existing Wording: The client can indicate whether the entire resource is returned using the HTTP return preference:

Proposed Wording: Servers SHALL return the entire resource content as it is represented in their system.

Comment:

Servers may transform content received from the client and that server-native representation of content should be conveyed to clients

is voted on by

BALLOT-1672 Negative - Nell Lapres : 2015-May-FHIR R1