2015May core #1329 - Should Immunization.reported be allowed if Immunization.wasNotGiven=true?

XMLWordPrintableJSON

    • Type: Question
    • Resolution: Not Persuasive
    • Priority: Medium
    • FHIR Core (FHIR)
    • DSTU1 [deprecated]
    • Public Health
    • Immunization
    • Hide

      2015-06-11 PHER: seems like a reasonable constraint. (8-0-2)

      2015-07-09 PHER: Previously thought of as a reasonable constraint to not allow an immunization to be reported if Not Given= True.

      Could be looked at as reporting on refusals. Could you document a historical refusal? These would be separate refusals.

      We shouldn't add a constraint if there isn't a use case for that constraint.

      Craig- we don't need a constraint here, but we might need to go back and review constraints to see if there are other needed constraints.

      Joginder, would like to deal with this item in isolation and would like to see review of current and addition of new constraints separately.

      *Motion: Joginder moves to reopen issue. *

      Second: Erin Holt

      Vote: 9, 0, 0

      Motion: Joginder moves that we will respond to this question stating that there is not hard and fast use case for this and therefore will leave as is.

      Second: Craig

      Vote: 9,0,0

      Show
      2015-06-11 PHER: seems like a reasonable constraint. (8-0-2) 2015-07-09 PHER: Previously thought of as a reasonable constraint to not allow an immunization to be reported if Not Given= True. Could be looked at as reporting on refusals. Could you document a historical refusal? These would be separate refusals. We shouldn't add a constraint if there isn't a use case for that constraint. Craig- we don't need a constraint here, but we might need to go back and review constraints to see if there are other needed constraints. Joginder, would like to deal with this item in isolation and would like to see review of current and addition of new constraints separately. *Motion: Joginder moves to reopen issue. * Second: Erin Holt Vote: 9, 0, 0 Motion: Joginder moves that we will respond to this question stating that there is not hard and fast use case for this and therefore will leave as is. Second: Craig Vote: 9,0,0
    • 9-0-0

      Existing Wording: N/A

      Proposed Wording: N/A

      Comment:

      Should Immunization.reported be allowed if Immunization.wasNotGiven=true?

            Assignee:
            Unassigned
            Reporter:
            Brett Marquard
            Watchers:
            2 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: